The madness of mobbing

We shall draw from the heart of suffering itself the means of inspiration and survival.  Winston Churchill

The mobbing instinct

What do birds, meerkats, chimpanzees, seals, squirrels and fish have in common with humans? Probably several things, but one thing they share is that certain examples of these species engage in mobbing behaviour. Mobbing involves a series of abusive actions in order to remove a threat to a group. Ethologist Konrad Lorenz applied the word mobbing to animal and bird behaviour in the 1960s. One example of an ornithological mobber is the Australian noisy miner bird, colonies of which erupt into a chorus signalling alarm at the approach of a predator such as a goanna, snake, or hawk. The birds then act co-operatively to fly around the predator, striking, diving, clicking and snapping at it until the predator is injured, is still, or leaves. Noisy miners also gang up on fellow members of the colony to drive them out. On the other side, owls can be targets of mobbing, particularly if they are injured and visible during the day. Small birds surround the owl, sending out an alarm call to beckon more birds to the mob, and infect them with their mobbing behaviour. The birds come close to the owl to display, peck or swoop at it until the owl leaves. In animals, mobbing can occur against predators from different species or even against members of their own species in a bid for individual and group survival. In humans, the invective is directed against fellow members of an organisation in order to oust them from groups or places.

Mobbing can happen anywhere

It is the involvement of both the group and the organisation in the abuse against a target that differentiates mobbing from bullying, which can involve a single offender harassing a target. As Kenneth Westhues states on his website devoted to mobbing in academia, mobbing represents “the bursting forth of two instincts at once; the instinct to join with others in an unusually cohesive group, and the instinct to destroy a target”. No one is safe: it occurs amongst children at school, amongst adults in the workplace, amongst academics, teachers, healthcare and legal professionals, in clubs and associations, everywhere. It can happen from the top down, when subordinates are mobbed, in can happen upwards, when people gang up on leaders, or it can happen sideways, to peers of equal standing. Mobbing represents a co-operative campaign of prolonged and frequent harassment by a group who views itself as the superior and righteous “in” group, and the target as a deviant outsider. Other names for mobbing include “ganging up”, and “psychic terror”.

In Sweden in the 1970s, physician Peter-Paul Heinemann applied the concept of mobbing to group aggression in children and adults. Soon after in the 1980s, also in Sweden, Heinz Leymann developed comprehensive research and concepts related to mobbing in workplaces. On his website, the late Leymann acknowledges that the concept of mobbing is an old one, stemming back to the beginning of various cultures. Many examples of mobbing are scattered through history and culture; the Salem witch hunts and William Golding’s Lord of the Flies are two famous examples.  So although the practice of mobbing is ancient, the research is relatively recent. It has however attracted multidisciplinary interest, particularly as it appears to be a global public health problem.

In their recent publication, Mobbing: Causes, Consequences and Solutions (Oxford University Press, 2012), Maureen Duffy and Len Sperry define mobbing as “the targeting of an individual or group of individuals within an organisation or school and the subjecting of that individual or group of individuals to a series of abusive and humiliating behaviours designed to cast them in a negative light, destabilise them, create suspicion about their worth as members of the organisation and, ultimately, to either force them out of the organisation or to render them as suspect and unworthy while remaining within the organisation.”

The measurement of abuse in schools and workplaces is often subsumed under the headings of bullying or harassment, so prevalence rates aren’t always easy to disentangle and compare. But let’s take the unscientific approach, and ask how many of you have been involved in a situation in which a person was ganged up on and victimised, either subtly or overtly? I would say there is a good chance that many of you have, whether as a target, a bystander, or a participant. The research that does exist shows that mobbing is common, and a global public health problem. A 2010 survey by the Workplace Bullying Institute showed that in the American workplace alone, 35% had experience bullying first-hand, and 15% had witnessed it. We can assume that many of these cases were in fact examples of mobbing.

How do mobbers mob?

Mobbers use an arsenal of direct and indirect unpleasant behaviours to undermine their victim: character assassination through malicious rumours and falsehoods; ostracism; hostile verbal and non-verbal attacks; organising others to join the attack; sabotage of work or personal belongings; and often blaming the target as the problem, using psychological labels or negative terminology. As Duffy and Sperry are careful to point out, mobbing is symptomatic of a dysfunctional environment. The group and organisational dynamics explain the mobbing, not the personal characteristics of the target alone. Individual attributes are relevant only in how they interact with the group and organisational context. Certain environments are more prone to abuse than others, for example those that value productivity over people. People in groups become infected by the mobbing, and sometimes reasonable people might act unreasonably because of the group dynamic. There is also a sense that acting as part of a group reduces individual responsibility.

The organisation may unwittingly become part of the mobbing by ignoring the problem, or blaming the victim. Indeed, it seems rare that an organisation is actively helpful in addressing mobbing, or that victims get appropriate reparation. Organisations are part of the problem, and are often unlikely to have the resources to respond to individual problems without putting the benefit of the organisation first. For example, people who have been mobbed might follow reporting procedures in their organisation, but the people who respond, such as Human Resource officers or senior managers, have a conflict of interest. To acknowledge a member has been mobbed is to admit liability to some degree, and a failure of duty of care. Not only that, it might involve allegations of misconduct and consequences against its leaders. It seems that organisations often feel it is in its best interest to ignore mobbing, although the cost in terms of employee turnover, group morale, absenteeism and sick pay can be substantial. Not only that, but mobbers are likely to strike again.

The effects of mobbing

So, what of individual targets? How does mobbing affect them? Duffy and Sperry acknowledge that the main experience of targets is loss: loss of self confidence and identity, loss of self respect and dignity, loss of sense of belonging, loss of belief in a fair world and in the humanity of others, loss of adequate functioning professionally and socially, loss of mental and physical health, loss of income, loss of lifestyle, loss of coping resources…  loss in nearly every domain. Citing Leymann, ‘loss of coping resources… a feeling of desperation and total helplessness, a feeling of great rage about lack of legal remedies, great anxiety and despair’. Physical consequences include headaches, gastrointestinal and cardiac problems, impaired immune functioning, sudden death or suicide. Psychological consequences can include anxiety, depression, or symptoms similar to those of post-traumatic stress disorder, such as hypervigilance and intrusive thoughts. On top of this, there are a whole host of negative feelings and consequences: disbelief, shock, denial, loneliness, avoidance behaviour, feelings of powerlessness, inferiority and humiliation. Add to this eating and sleeping difficulties, increased stress and fatigue, and a tendency to engage in addictive behaviours, and you have a veritable cocktail of personal collapse. It is little wonder that targets start acting differently, but the mobbers can take even these behavioural changes to use as further evidence for their campaign. It is also little wonder that targets might harbour the desire for recognition and revenge, sometimes fatally so if the target resorts to homicide. And of course, family members and relationships of targets inevitably suffer, as targets withdraw, shut down, become obsessed, and require additional support.

Targets of mobbing are exposed to a prolonged and frequent series of abusive events, or cumulative trauma. Mobbers are often covert, so targets cannot always directly identify and deal with the many insidious and damaging behaviours that slowly erode everything the target values. Indeed, targets often blame themselves, and are slow to recognise what is happening. Once they have recognised it, it is often hard to produce evidence or specific things to include in formalised grievances. As Evelyn Field, psychologist and bully blocking expert says, it is hard to treat until targets receive validation and justice. This, however, is often difficult to do, as targets have to fight to solve the problems themselves. Simply doing this requires a certain level of confidence, energy and clarity that the victims might not have. It also requires the organisation to recognise and respond fairly and respectfully to allegations.

Targets are placed in a no-win situation. If they stay in the toxic environment, they may continue to be exposed to the abusive behaviours that are damaging their psychological and physical health. They might not easily be able to leave, if circumstances do not permit it. Even if they do leave, they will be followed by the effects of mobbing – it is likely they will need to ask for references from their mobbing colleagues, and once they are in a new situation they may try to avoid similar labels, so change their behaviour or underperform in order to escape attention. They can fight, but this is often not effective or viable if the targets are suffering, they can flight, if their circumstances permit it, or they can freeze and go into emotional shutdown. The latter is a common response.

Anti-mobbing action

The costs of mobbing to both organisation and targets are substantial. To prevent it, Duffy and Sperry recommend proaction, not simply reaction, at every level, starting with specific anti-mobbing legislation. Sweden introduced anti-mobbing legislation in 1993, and other places that have followed suit include France, Belgium, the Netherlands, Quebec, some states in the US, and South Australia. Mostly, legislation addresses mobbing in the workplace. As “The Healthy Workplace Bill” formulated in the US by the founders of the Workplace Bullying Institute makes clear, protection needs to be non-status based and protect people from psychological and physical harm in the workplace. While some places have anti-bullying legislation addressing bullying in schools, mobbing itself as a distinct problem has yet to be included in legislation. Another problem is that mobbing can occur elsewhere, not just as school or in the workplace. Robert Clarke MP, Attorney-General in Victoria, Australia, has advocated for the federal adoption of Victoria’s anti-bullying legislative changes introduced in 2011, known as “Brodie’s Law” in reference to the young girl who committed suicide after being the victim of bullying at work. An admirable aspect of these legislative changes is that they criminalise bullying irrespective of where it occurs; workplaces, schools, universities, anywhere. To fully address the scope of the problem, anti-mobbing legislation would also need to similarly criminalise psychological harassment by a group and organisation in any environment.

In terms of organisations and groups being proactive, Duffy and Sperry recommend introduction and active enforcement of anti-mobbing policies, awareness and vigilance amongst staff, safe reporting structures, respectful responses to allegations of mobbing, and an overall valuing of tolerance, respect and diversity in the organisation with a focus on individuals as well as performance. For individual targets of mobbing, intervention needs to be handled carefully, with therapists who are experienced in handling trauma. Blaming the victim, or focusing on the target as the source of the problem, can retraumatise the targets. Indeed, many targets appear to be higher than average achievers, some with the propensity to stand up for what is right. Such characteristics might be why they were perceived as a threat in the first place. Victims need to be carefully guided towards reinstating some control and sense of purpose in their life, towards positive social support and good health. Targets need to know that they are not to blame, that they are not beyond redemption, that this behaviour is unfortunately normal, and that they can work towards healing and a future.

 

Article 12, The Universal Declaration of Human RightsNo one shall be subjected to arbitrary interference with his privacy, family, home or correspondence, nor to attacks upon his honour and reputation. Everyone has the right to the protection of the law against such interference or attacks.

 

34 thoughts on “The madness of mobbing

  1. Hi. I am so sorry to hear of your troubles, it sounds like you have been targeted by some bullies. It can feel very lonely being a target, please do try and find some support outside the workplace to advise and help you. Try your doctor, or one of the specialist bullying websites like the Workplace Bullying Institute, which has a forum for sharing your problems, see http://www.workplacebullying.org/talk/. It is also an excellent resource. I too have been in a situation much like yours, including criminal acts against me. I have reported these to the police, who do not seem to have taken much notice. It is from this position that I offer you the following thoughts that have helped me. 1: unfortunately, you are not alone. Many, many people have been the target of mobs and bullies, we share and understand your pain. 2: it is not your fault; nothing justifies that sort of behaviour. 3: you can move on from this, you just need to read some of the resources, find someone impartial to listen and maybe support you, and for you to plot the best way out of this situation. 4: if you can manage it, try and keep evidence or documentation of what is happening to you. It can feel like a real drag and reinforce your pain temporarily, but it is also a relief to know that you have written down what has happened in case you need to refer to it in future. Bullies will deny their actions, of course. And if you are like me, your mind will be clouded with distress and sometimes writing it down can help you make sense of it later.
    Good luck, I really hope you find some help and work out ways to approach this situation.

  2. Hi. I am currently being mobbed. I have had my trousers with keys taken from my bag, lucky I had a uniform so I could wear it home and a spare key tied under my car. My bank card got removed from my wallet, cash removed from my wallet, some people are so comfortable with making life difficult and you would never know that they are the ones doing it.it has progressed now to the point where my job is so hard that nobody will work with me. Ostracising you further. Nobody in managment listens they say we are trying to help you. Truth is it is coming from high up to gain a result of removal.I don’t really know what to do. Except hang in there.

  3. Hi, I am glad the information was helpful. I do not have a blog subscription facility.

  4. Magnificent beat ! I wish to apprentice while you amend your website, how can i subscribe for a blog web site?
    The account helped me a acceptable deal. I had been tiny bit acquainted of this your broadcast provided bright clear concept

  5. Thank you for some other informative website. Where else may
    I am getting that type of information written in such a perfect manner?
    I’ve a project that I’m just now operating on, and I have
    been at the glance out for such info.

  6. I’m very happy to discover this page. I need to to thank you for your time for this particularly wonderful read!! I definitely loved every bit of it and I have you book marked to check out new stuff in your web site.

  7. Fantastic, it’s like you read my thoughts. A essential article, thank you.

  8. Pretty section of content. I just stumbled upon your site and I actually enjoyed account your blog posts.

  9. It’s remarkable to go to see this web site and reading the views of all mates on the topic of this piece of writing, while I am also keen of getting knowledge.

  10. I’m glad you found it interesting. I don’t offer contact details, but am happy to respond to comments on this site.
    Thanks

  11. I blog quite often and I trulу thanκ
    уou foг уοur contеnt.
    This gгeat aгticle hаs гeally ρeaked mу intеreѕt.
    I аm gоing to take а note of youг sitе
    аnd κeеp chеcking for new dеtails

  12. Neat post. There’s a problem together with your website in web explorer, might check this? A good part of folks will pass over your magnificent writing because of this problem.

  13. whoah this blog is magnificent i like studying
    your articles. Keep up the good work! You understand, many individuals are hunting round for this information,
    you can aid them greatly.

  14. This is a topic that is near to my heart… Thank you!
    Exactly where are your contact details though?

  15. I am rеally inspirеd together wіth yοur writing skills and also with the foгmat іn youг wеblog.
    Iѕ that this а paid subject mattеr or did you customize it уοuгself?
    Eithеr ωay κeеρ up the niсе qualitу writing, it’s rare to peer a great blog like this one today..

  16. Hello, I think уour site might be having brοwѕeг cоmpatibility isѕues.
    Whеn I look at уour wеbsite іn Fiгefοx, it lοoks fine but when оρеning in
    Internet Explorer, it has some overlappіng. Ι juѕt ωanteԁ tο giѵe you а quick heaԁs up!

    Otheг thеn that, excellent blоg!

  17. I’m glad you read it. Use the comment facility as you have already done if you want to communicate further.

  18. Thank you for the auspicious writeup. It in fact was a amusement account it.

    Look advanced to far added agreeable from you! By the way, how can
    we communicate?

  19. A motivating discussion is definitely worth comment. I think that you should
    write more about this subject, it might not be a taboo subject
    but generally people do not discuss these subjects. To the next!
    Kind regards!!

  20. I have been browsing online greater than 3 hours
    as of late, yet I never found any interesting article like yours.

    It’s lovely value sufficient for me. In my opinion, if all web owners and bloggers made excellent content as you probably did, the internet shall be a lot more helpful than ever before.

  21. You need to be a part of a contest for one of the finest sites on the net. I am going to recommend this site!

  22. I simply want to tell you that I am very new to blogs and truly loved your blog. Very likely I’m going to bookmark your site . You certainly have fantastic articles and reviews. Bless you for sharing your blog.

  23. This happens often. Individuals are terminated within days of filing an EEOC complaint and retaliated against after being subjected to harassment and threats.

  24. Hi. Good to hear from you. Unfortunately, I am not in a position to correspond via email about mobbing or harassment. I am so very sorry to hear that you have been the target of bullying. All I can do is offer you some ideas about how to move forwards. 1) Get medical help and help your treating professionals understand your situation; it is crucial that they know the context. It sounds as though you might have already had some medical diagnoses, hopefully you are getting some support and treatment from appropriate health professionals.
    2) If it is not too painful, share your story with some of your personal contacts, so they understand what you are going through.

    There are some good research papers on the internet that might be useful for showing to the people around you to help them understand your situation; for example, http://www.choixdecarriere.com/pdf/6573/2010/DuffySperry2007.pdf
    There are also usually some good resources on the web for finding mental health support in your country.

    I am however in a position to help you tell your story if you think that might help you, just to share it here in a supportive environment. If you want to do that, post it as a comment (bear in mind that I might need to moderate it).

    However you proceed, please know that you are not alone, that some of us out here understand some of what you are going through, and we wish you all the best. We hope that some ways to move forwards into a better, healthier place will present themselves soon.

  25. I´ve made a copy of what Olli wrote : many thanks for taking this chance to speak about this, Personally i think strongly regarding it and I make use of learning about this subject. When possible, as you gain data, please update this website with new information. I’ve found it extremely useful.
    I would love to talk to the admin / the one who wrote this text above.
    I´ve exposed to severe harassment & bullying, and is left with 7 diagnoses …
    Please e-mail me :-)

  26. I’m glad it helped. If there are any particular things you would like to know about, let me know and I will see whether I can find any information about it.
    Take care.

  27. Many thanks for taking this chance to speak about this, Personally i think strongly regarding it and I make use of learning about this subject. When possible, as you gain data, please update this website with new information. I’ve found it extremely useful.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>